(Bankr. S.D. Ind. Feb. 4, 2015)
The bankruptcy court denies the creditor’s motion to dismiss or convert the chapter 7 case. The creditor had obtained a judgment against the debtor and her employer for the debtor’s unlawful accessing and dissemination of the creditor’s medical information. The creditor sought dismissal of the case under § 707(b) (failure of means test), but the court determined the debtor’s debts were not primarily consumer debts and thus that section did not apply. While the judgment was not a business debt, that did not necessarily mean it was a consumer debt. The creditor also sought dismissal for cause under § 707(a). The court recognized that seeking to pay a large debt of one creditor is a factor in favor of dismissal, but that alone did not warrant dismissal for cause. There was no evidence of the debtor’s ability to pay the large judgment. Finally, the creditor alternatively sought to convert the case to chapter 11, but the court denied the request, finding no credible evidence of the debtor’s ability to pay the debt or that chapter 11 would benefit creditors more than chapter 7 (in part because the creditor could collect the judgment from the debtor’s employer). Opinion below.
Author: Matt Lindblom